A Tale of Two Batgirls: Comparing ‘Batman: Arkham’ and ‘Gotham Knights’ for the Best of the Best

The recent releases of Batman: Arkham and Gotham Knights have given fans of the Batman franchise a choice between two vastly different experiences. While both feature a version of Batgirl, it begs the question: which really has the best Batgirl? Arkham has the classic Batgirl we all know and love, while Gotham Knights offer a more modern take on the character. Let’s analyze both versions of Batgirl, looking at their abilities, story arcs, and overall influence in their respective games. Let’s also consider how these two versions of the character compare to each other, ultimately determining which offers the better version of Batgirl.

Batgirl is a prominent figure in both Gotham Knights and the Batman: Arkham series. In the Arkham series, Barbara Gordon is portrayed as Oracle and often appears alongside Nightwing who is a more jovial figure. In Gotham Knights, however, the focus is placed much more closely on the sidekicks who are the ones defending Gotham after Batman’s death. Although Batgirl appears in both series, one does her character more justice than the other. In the Arkham series, Batgirl is merely a supporting character whereas, in Gotham Knights, she is a playable hero. This allows having a much deeper and more unique experience of the character than in the Arkham series.

A Tale of Two Batgirls: Confronting the Chaos of Gotham and Arkham Knights

In the Arkham series, Batgirl is portrayed as a tech-savvy vigilante with a strong moral compass. She is a master at using gadgets and computers and is willing to risk her life to take down criminals. On the other hand, in Gotham Knights, Batgirl is much more of a martial artist and has a more reckless attitude. She is not afraid to confront her enemies face to face and is a skilled fighter. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference as to which Batgirl is the best.

History of Barbara Gordon

The Batman: Arkham series has featured Barbara Gordon in a notable role. Although she does not become playable as Batgirl until the Arkham Knight DLC, she has been an essential part of the games. In Rocksteady’s, she is presented as Batman’s devoted contact and technology expert Oracle, a persona she assumes after being left paralyzed by the Joker. Arkham Origins provides a glimpse at Barbara’s imminent career as a superhero, as she assists Batman with an investigation. Batgirl is a playable character in Batman: Arkham Knight DLC A Matter of Family.

In the DLC, she is available in both challenge maps and a prequel storyline. Batman: Arkham has been a great platform for Barbara Gordon to be a part of. Though she is not playable as Batgirl until the Arkham Knight DLC, her character has been integral in setting up her superhero career. Her identity as Oracle in the first two Rocksteady games shows her loyalty to Batman, while Arkham Origins sets the foundation for her to become a superhero. The Batman: Arkham Knight DLC A Matter of Family allows her to be playable in challenge maps and a prequel storyline and is a great addition to the series.


In the Batman: Arkham series, Barbara Gordon serves an important role, however, Gotham Knights let players take the role of Batgirl and explore an open world. She has acrobatic combat, her own unique abilities, and gadgets that make her stand out from the other characters of the Bat Family. Batgirl is quick and agile and has the Perfect Evade skill which enables her to launch powerful counterattacks when she dodges at the right time. Players can further customize Batgirl with four skill trees, giving her the possibility to become a brawler, use her technological proficiency, or call a drone for help in combat.

The Dynamic Duo: How Batgirl Helps Batman Achieve Success in Arkham Games

Barbara Gordon, also known as Batgirl, is an essential part of Batman’s mission in the Arkham video game series. However, in the game, Gotham Knights, playing as Batgirl is an especially singular experience. She can only be controlled in play in Arkham Knight, and her hacking device allows her to stand apart from other characters such as Robin, Nightwing, and Red Hood. Additionally, Batgirl has four distinct skill trees and her own distinctive narrative arc that deals with the death of Batman and the disappearance of her father Jim Gordon.

batman arkham knights

Gotham Knights Bring Barbara Gordon to New Heights as Batgirl – Letting Oracle Take a Backseat

The Batman: Arkham games gave us an insight into Oracle’s capabilities, but Gotham Knights have taken Barbara Gordon’s Batgirl to a whole new level. The character has her own distinctive way of getting around and an array of original skill trees that reflect her knowledge of martial arts and tech, which she acquired through her training with Batman. In Arkham Knight, however, Batgirl feels like an alternate version of the Dark Knight himself.

Wrap Up

The debate between Batman: Arkham and Gotham Knights on which really has the best Batgirl has been a long-standing one. Ultimately, it comes down to personal opinion. Each game offers its own unique take on the character and the adventures she finds herself in. Arkham offers a darker, more action-oriented version of Batgirl while Gotham Knights provide a lighter, comedic tone. It really depends on what kind of experience you’re looking for and how you prefer to play. If you’re looking for an intense, action-packed experience, then Arkham is definitely the way to go.

It offers a more realistic take on the character and her adventures, and the combat is top-notch. On the other hand, if you’re looking for a more lighthearted experience, then Gotham Knights are the way to go. The game still retains the darkness and mystery of the Batman universe, but it gives a more comedic spin to the character. Whichever version of Batgirl you prefer, both Arkham and Gotham Knights offer amazing experiences and an incredibly faithful take on the character. Whether you’re a fan of comics, movies, or TV shows, both games have something to offer. So in the end, it really just comes down to personal preference.

Anoosha Khan
Anoosha Khan

Anoosha Khan is a film critic and entertainment editor based in the UK. She has been reporting about celebs and movies for WatchinUK for the past year.

Articles: 951

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *